
Cars parked along Highway 20 near popular trailheads can create safety issues for drivers and pedestrians.
Fall phenomenon’s popularity creates crowding problems
Larch March. Larch Madness. The terms only begin to convey the annual frenzy over the spectacle of the conifers whose delicate needles turn gold for a few precious weeks each fall.
But unlike some viral internet phenomena, larch madness has a very tangible virtual footprint, with nearly 8,000 people descending on a beloved trail in the North Cascades in a single weekend to see the trees up close.
Passion for the trees has been growing over the last decade, with photos and videos on social media driving the craze.
Larch grow primarily at higher elevations, and there are several easily accessible areas on the North Cascades Highway where people flock to admire the trees. The crowds completely overwhelm trailhead parking areas, particularly at the two most popular sites near Washington and Rainy passes — Blue Lake and Heather/Maple Pass — meaning that hikers park for miles along the state highway and walk to the trailhead.
With cars straddling the white line and a steady stream of people walking in the lane of traffic, Mazama resident Jason Paulsen reported the situation to the Washington State Patrol (WSP), worried that the situation would result in a tragedy.
“It’s off the charts. I can’t understand why someone would pull up and see that — and still park and walk a mile and a half to the trailhead,” said Paulsen, who took photos of drivers trying to park while pedestrians navigated the roadway. “By the grace of god, no one was killed.”
Although the trails are busy every year, this year was the busiest ever, Methow Valley Ranger District (MVRD) Recreation Staff Rosemary Seifried said. It was the perfect storm, with beautiful weather and glorious golden color, she said.
During the first weekend of October alone, MVRD counted 7,600 people on Saturday and Sunday at the Heather/Maple Pass trailhead, which provides access to both the 7.2-mile Maple Pass loop and a 1-mile paved path to Rainy Lake. Another 2,000 people hiked there that Thursday and Friday.
Although MVRD has tracked usage in previous years, they can’t make direct comparisons because they used different counting technology. This year, the ranger district used infrared sensors, considered highly accurate, Seifried said.
Still, “Saturday, Oct. 3, was definitely the single highest-use day we have recorded at the Maple Pass trail” — probably twice as many people as in past years, she said.
At Blue Lake, a shorter out-and-back trail near Washington Pass, there were 2,854 people that weekend, plus another 850 on Thursday and Friday.
The thousands of hikers didn’t dim the enthusiasm online, with many people saying the scenery was worth the crowds. “I have never cared to see larches and have honestly been turned off in the past by the obsession across Reddit and other platforms. I now understand the craze,” said one commenter on Reddit. “They really are jarringly stunning, and their fleeting nature creates a sense of crazed madness to see them at peak despite the hordes of people there to do exactly the same.”
Others were aghast over the crush of people. “2 miles of cars parked on both sides of the hwy! Might as well just go to Disneyland!” one said. Another suggested that the state step in to help protect our parks, “since federal agencies have dropped the ball.”
Wide-ranging impacts
All the trails in the area are prone to erosion and home to fragile alpine vegetation, and susceptible to other impacts from heavy use.
Human waste and “toilet-paper flowers” are always a problem, because people aren’t educated about what to do, Seifried said. With infrastructure not designed for thousands of people, MVRD staff find garbage from people’s vehicles left at trailheads and overflowing trash bins in the bathrooms, she said. People leave doggie-poop bags everywhere along the trail.
The ranger district and trails organizations use wilderness rangers and volunteers to educate people about protecting fragile mountain environments and leaving no trace in the mountains. Community volunteers help clean and maintain trails. Still, you can’t have that many people without an impact, Seifried said.
There’s definitely a need for more education to protect the heather and subalpine environment, Methow Valley Trails Collaborative Director Allen Jircik said. That includes explaining where it’s OK to walk or pitch a tent, and where it’s safe and appropriate to park. The collaborative, which has a contract for work in the area, and MVRD are doing as much as they can with limited resources, he said.
The collaborative has worked on the Heather/Maple trail several times in recent years to address erosion issues created when people cut switchbacks, Jircik said. This summer, trail crews installed clearer barriers and ropes to delineate the trail and posted signs about areas closed for restoration. If you harden trail surfaces enough, having more people hike them will not cause additional damage. By and large, people respect the trail markers, Seifried said.
Despite those efforts, the Heather/Maple Pass trail is inevitably affected by the heavy use. With an unbroken line of hikers, people constantly step aside to let others pass, widening the trail from 2 feet to 6 feet, Paulsen said. One attraction of the loop trail is that it can be hiked in either direction, so people inevitably pass hikers going the other way.
This fall, the Washington Trails Association (WTA) also stationed ambassadors at busy trailheads. WTA ambassadors have a welcoming presence but no enforcement role — they remind people to stay on the trail, explain leave-no-trace practices, and provide info about safe parking and required passes, WTA Magazine Editor Jessi Loerch said. They suggest people have a back-up plan in case it’s busy, she said.
To Paulsen, on-site ambassadors aren’t likely to protect fragile alpine environments. If people are careless enough to park in unsafe areas and walk along the road, there’s little hope of educating them about trail etiquette — “it makes me sick,” he said.
Not advertised
Although the ranger district doesn’t track where hikers are from, they know people travel from all over the country to visit the area, which is seen as a national resource with world-class trails, Seifried said.
The U.S. Forest Service also doesn’t steer people toward any particular trail. “We give information, and we provide the resource and manage the resource for people, but we don’t publicize anything,” Seifried said. MVRD will direct hikers to certain trails if someone asks for a trail that isn’t busy, but most people get their information elsewhere, she said.
The Okanogan-Wenatchee National Forest website would never publish a list of top-10 larch hikes, Seifried said. But chambers of commerce and local media do highlight certain areas.
Washington State Parks took a different approach, highlighting less-visited areas. State Parks likes to raise awareness of splendid fall color in other regions, including Pearrygin Lake for its quaking aspen and other parks that feature big-leaf maples, state parks Communications Consultant Meryl Lassen said.
“We love to tell people about the western larches in and around state parks in central, north and southeastern Washington. They tend to peak a bit later than the subalpine larches up high, so, in an ideal year, folks could get an extra weekend of larch marching in,” she said.
The big crowds don’t necessarily boost revenue for the ranger district, which has been struggling under reduced budgets. Although people need a day or season pass to park at the trailheads, the money doesn’t go directly to MVRD unless the pass is purchased at their headquarters in Winthrop, Seifried said. Fees help cover maintenance at trailheads, including toilet pumping and supplies, and the high use adds expenses, requiring more frequent pumping and additional toilet paper.
Safety concerns
This year, MVRD collaborated with the Washington State Department of Transportation (WSDOT) and the state patrol to improve sightlines at the busy trailheads on the North Cascades Highway. WSDOT added no-parking signs at trail intersections to help prevent vehicles from blocking them, WSDOT North Central Region Communications Manager Summer Derrey said. The signs and reader boards about traffic congestion helped with safety, Seifried said.
WSDOT is tasked with regulating parking on state highways, which are designed, built and maintained with multimodal safety as a core principle. It is lawful to park safely and to walk on the side of state highways, unless designated otherwise, Derrey said. There are similar parking issues along state highways near ski resorts at Stevens Pass and Snoqualmie Pass, she said.
WSDOT also tried to manage the situation with posts on social media. “Beware the Ides of Larch,” one said, suggesting people find another hike if the parking lot is full, and reminding people to watch for pedestrians on the highway.
“Larches are iconic here in the PNW, so it’s no wonder they draw crowds every fall. But if you’re chasing those Instagram moments, be prepared for a bitter dose of reality. Stay safe and respect our natural areas!” WSDOT said.
The state patrol is aware of the situation but hadn’t issued any citations as of mid-October, Public Information Officer Trooper Jeremy Weber said. “WSP can tow vehicles if they are left over 24 hours, or if they are parked blocking the roadway,” he said. “WSP has the jurisdiction for the roadway only. Pedestrians can walk along the highway as long as they’re not in it. Obviously not suggested, but it’s not illegal.”
Several state troopers checked the area this year, but didn’t find any violations, Weber said, although he conceded that limited staffing makes it difficult to be on the highway all the time. WSP and WSDOT plan to post additional safety information next year, Weber said.
Management options
Ranger district staff always talk about ways to improve the situation — particularly safety, Seifried said.
While the trails are popular all summer, it’s primarily three weekends in the fall that get such intense use. Other factors including summer wildfire smoke are changing recreation patterns, meaning people increasingly seek out trails in the spring or fall. People in Washington like to hike, and the population is growing, Seifried said.
Seifried collects ideas about what other areas do to address similar issues — for example, wildflower viewing for a few weeks out of the year. Those strategies include permits, timed entries and shuttles. Many of these approaches would involve a formal analysis and public comment, so they couldn’t be implemented quickly, she said.
Moreover, managing a permit system would require intensive staffing. If people had to get a permit — and then discovered that no one was checking for them — that would be a problem. When people follow the rules and discover others haven’t, that is very upsetting to them, Seifried said.
The logistics of a timed-entry system would be particularly challenging at the trailheads on the North Cascades Highway, since it’s a through road, not a designated entrance. MVRD has also contemplated shuttle systems, but that would just add shuttled hikers to the large group who drive themselves and park, Seifried said.
Enlarging a trailhead parking area would require a national environmental review because it would entail site disturbance. Even adding bathrooms would require an analysis, Seifried said.
They’re also aware that limiting use in one area generally means people will go somewhere else, just transferring the impacts. “It’s an age-old question — whether it’s better to spread use out and disperse it, or to concentrate it,” Seifried said.
Seifried pointed to the Enchantments near Leavenworth, where the Forest Service has required a permit for an overnight hike since 1987. The Forest Service receives approximately 44,000 applicants for the 2,000 permits. With the increased popularity of trail running, many people now do a long trip in a single day, Seifried said.
In a recent article, the Seattle Times looked at the permit system implemented by British Columbia Parks, which now requires day-use permits at the busiest sites. Some areas require permits only on weekends, but the most popular places need permits all the time.
The program rankled the outdoor-recreation community, who complained that it didn’t take carrying capacity into account and ended up displacing hikers to other unmanaged sites, according to the Seattle Times reporting. But law enforcement and First Nations hailed the effort, saying it had relieved crowding and eliminated parking on highways.
Then again, MVRD doesn’t necessarily consider the crowding a problem — other than the safety concerns of parking and walking on the highway. “A lot of people are very happy. You see this huge diversity of user types on that trail. That’s a good thing — people getting out, enjoying a hike,” Seifried said.
“There’s lots of trails with solitude, so it’s not hard to get away from people if that’s what you want,” she said.





