Lloyd Logging not decided on whether to appeal decision
For now, a gravel pit just outside of Winthrop is off the table.
Okanogan County’s hearing examiner has determined that Lloyd Logging’s permit for the pit 1 1/2 miles west of Winthrop had expired before the zoning for that area changed, meaning the pit could not be grandfathered in as an existing and permitted use.
The Oct. 22 decision by Hearing Examiner Andrew Kottkamp agreed with a group of five neighbors of the pit who argued there were no disputes of fact in the matter because Lloyd Logging had failed to renew its permit for a gravel pit and related operations at the site after the permit expired in 1989.
The county’s zoning code was amended in March 2000, prohibiting gravel pits in that low-density residential zone unless they were “existing/permitted sites,” Kottkamp said in his decision.
Kottkamp rejected an argument by Kutak Rock, the Spokane-based law firm representing Lloyd Logging, that multiple documents regarding gravel operations and inspections at the site from the 2000s demonstrate that the pit was operating and the county was aware of it.
But in separate responses to the neighbors’ petition for summary judgment, Kutak Rock and Okanogan County Chief Civil Deputy Prosecuting Attorney Esther Milner said that the relevant county documents from 1989 can’t be located.
The county has a record that its board of adjustment, which would have handled the permit renewal, informed Lloyd Logging in 1987 that the permit was up for renewal in 1989. There is also a document from 1989 saying the pit was due for inspection, Milner wrote. “During a search of historical records, however, County staff located documents stating that Board of Adjustment files from 1989 are missing,” she wrote.
Because there are two decades of references to operations at the pit after 1989 that consistently reflect governmental recognition of the permit as existing and valid, the matter can’t be resolved without additional fact-finding, Milner said. “Washington courts have recognized that the absence of an original document does not establish, as a matter of law, that the document never existed,” Milner wrote.
Although the 1989 files are missing, “the record contains substantial evidence that the County continued to treat CUP 80 [conditional-use permit 80] as in effect,” Kutak Rock said in their appeal. The pit has been operating continuously since 1985 and the county took no steps to stop it for 41 years, the attorneys said.
Bob Lloyd, secretary/treasurer of Lloyd Logging, said this week that the company also has not found anything in its files from 1989.
Even if there was a question of fact as to whether the property was actively in use as a gravel pit in March 2000, “there is no question of fact that the use was no longer lawfully permitted as of October 1989,” Kottkamp wrote. There was also no evidence that the permit was ever renewed — not in 1989, nor from 1990 through 2000, he wrote.
“Lloyd and the County’s entire defense of CUP 80 is a house of cards that presumes and assumes that CUP 80 was timely renewed and valid in March 2000 simply because Lloyd and the County assumed it had been and treated it as such,” Goldman said in the neighbors’ brief for summary judgment.
The lack of a valid permit at the time of the zoning change is key to the entire case, Goldman said in an interview this week. References in the county’s records since then don’t substitute for a properly renewed permit, he said.
Application for expansion
The county has been reviewing the matter because Lloyd Logging has applied to expand the pit from 10 to 41.84 acres and re-start excavating gravel and sand there. The county solicited public input on the application and has issued a set of proposed conditions on operations.
Kottkamp canceled a three-phase hearing on the matter that had been scheduled for Dec. 10, which was to have included Lloyd Logging’s appeal of some of the conditions the county had placed on operations at the pit. He was also going to consider the neighbors’ appeal of the existence of the pit, given the lapsed permit, and take testimony from the public about the proposed expansion and conditions to mitigate noise, lights and environmental impacts.
But because there were no questions of fact regarding the absence of a valid permit for the pit, Kottkamp dismissed all those issues as moot.
Cascade Concrete has been operating the Lloyd Logging pit for decades and currently uses the site to crush rock excavated from two nearby pits. The company has repeatedly stressed the need for a local source of rock and gravel. Trucking in rock, gravel and sand increases costs and means more truck traffic, diesel consumption, and wear and tear on roads, Lloyd Logging said in an advertisement about the issue published in the Methow Valley News.
Although the neighbors maintain that any operations require strict conditions to protect the environment, they agree that every community needs a local source of gravel. The neighbors have reached out to Lloyd Logging to develop mutually acceptable conditions, but the company has rejected all overtures, Goldman said.
Lloyd Logging has not decided whether to appeal the hearing examiner’s ruling, Lloyd said this week. A request for reconsideration would be due by Nov. 5 and an appeal to Okanogan County Superior Court would be due by Nov. 12. No decisions have been made to pursue either avenue, attorney Allen T. Miller with Kutak Rock said.





