Other utilities challenge BPA’s ‘spillage’ rate hike
The Okanogan County Electric Co-operative (OCEC) is postponing the rate hike associated with a surcharge being implemented by the Bonneville Power Administration (BPA).
OCEC had announced a 3% surcharge beginning in October, but because BPA won’t be implementing the extra charge until December, OCEC won’t collect the additional $0.0023 per kilowatt hour until January, OCEC informed its ratepayers last month. There will still be a line item for the “BPA Spill Surcharge” starting with the November bill.
The surcharge is the result of a federal court order requiring that additional water be spilled at federal hydroelectric dams on the Columbia River. Spilled water will go over the dams instead of through turbines, which BPA says will reduce the amount of hydropower produced.
BPA just launched the official process required to raise its rates this week, with a listing in the Federal Register. That process gives utilities the opportunity to comment or object. A decision on rates is expected in mid-December.
The Okanogan County Public Utility District (PUD) is aware of the court order requiring the BPA to increase spill but hasn’t proposed a rate increase at this time, PUD Public Information Officer Jessica McCarthy said.
“We won’t know the final cost, if any, until BPA completes its year-end financials and determines what charge may be necessary. To plan conservatively, the [PUD] has included an estimated $1 million in the current draft budget for this potential expense,” McCarthy said.
BPA has indicated that the surcharge will remain in place until the federal mandate is lifted — or until they can reflect these costs in the next BPA rate case, which goes into effect Oct. 1, 2028, OCEC said in a fact sheet about the surcharge.
Almost 130 utilities purchase hydropower from BPA, although the proportion of BPA power in their overall mix varies. OCEC gets about 80% of its power from BPA. OCEC is one of three utilities that already announced a surcharge to ratepayers.
Challenges to BPA
The decision to spill more water stems from a Feb. 25 court order connected with a lawsuit over the impacts of hydropower dams on salmon that goes back almost three decades.
Several conservation groups and representatives of public-power consumers have been challenging BPA. There are two main tracks — one connected with how to manage dams to protect endangered salmon, and one related to the rates BPA charges for power.
The plaintiffs contend that the federal agencies that operate the dams have not adequately protected salmon and steelhead, said Earthjustice attorney Michael Mayer, who is representing clean energy, conservation and fishing groups in the case over protections for salmon. He is also representing the NW Energy Coalition, the Idaho Conservation League and the Sierra Club, who are challenging BPA’s request for a rate increase.
Other utilities are not formal parties in the rate case but can submit comments, said Ben Otto, state and regional policy director for the NW Energy Coalition, which represents utilities in Washington, Oregon, Idaho and Montana within the Columbia River system.
Questions about surcharge
Although BPA has been talking about the need for a surcharge since the spring, they were “oddly silent” and didn’t file a request for a rate increase until Oct. 5, Mayer said. The deadline for utilities to intervene in the rate case is Oct. 6.
Earthjustice is questioning BPA’s claims that a surcharge is necessary. Although BPA said it needed $250 million — based on projections of an annual shortfall of about $85 million for each of three years — BPA’s third-quarter report showed they were $40 million ahead of projections, Mayer said. BPA’s fiscal year ended Oct. 1 and the fourth-quarter results won’t be released until November, but it would take a “serious cratering of finances” to wipe out that excess, he said.
OCEC General Manager Greg Mendonca believes BPA waited to request the rate hike because, since the February court order to spill more water, BPA has spent time trying to figure out how to reliably run operations in the river and provide for required recreation and irrigation.
Many factors affect BPA’s finances, including price, demand for power, and weather, but BPA is singling out the requirement to spill extra water for salmon as justification to raise rates, Mayer said. Spilling extra water over the turbines reduces the amount of hydropower they produce, but the request for higher rates ignores myriad other factors that determine BPA’s financial health. “BPA seems intent on just pointing the finger at salmon,” Mayer said.
Earthjustice contends that BPA’s rate increases stem in part from poor planning, and that BPA has neglected to invest in transmission lines or develop sources of cheap, clean energy. The groups are challenging whether it’s necessary for BPA to raise rates, rather than use its existing reserves, Otto said.
BPA’s request for a rate hike is an administrative process but, barring a major lawsuit, it’s just a matter of time and will go through as planned, Mendonca said. The additional spills have been happening since the spring, and BPA is now dealing with the financial effects of those spills, he said.
Although BPA rate cases are “super-complex,” this is the standard approval process, Mendonca said. BPA posts a public notice, which is followed by a comment period, testimony and cross-examination. The final decision is made by the BPA administrator, meaning approval is likely, he said.
Occasionally a request for a rate increase is adjusted after input, but Mendonca doesn’t anticipate that this time. The only difference is that the process is expedited, whereas it usually takes about eight months, he said.
Most utilities don’t have an adequate cushion to absorb a 6% increase from BPA, Mendonca said. “The money is real — BPA has to recover their costs, and we have to recover ours as well,” he said.
Editors Note: This story was edited on October 12, 2026





