Public reaction has been strongly negative
After hearing nearly unanimous opposition to data centers from hundreds of county residents, the Okanogan County Planning Commission is working on recommendations to the county commissioners about whether data centers should be permitted in the county — and, if so, where.
The local discussion comes at a time of widespread opposition to data centers nationwide. Input to Okanogan County has been overwhelmingly negative, with just a single person speaking about the benefits of data centers when the county solicited public comment this summer, said Planning Commissioner John Crandall, who represents the Methow Valley. “If we’re representatives of that, it’s very clear what the public is asking of the county,” he said.
Okanogan County proposed allowing data centers in industrial zones only. But during a follow-up discussion with the planning commission at the Sept. 22 County commissioners’ meeting, Okanogan County Commissioner Andy Hover acknowledged that the proposal restricting data centers to industrial zones wasn’t viable.
“I did not know that the only industrial area that exists in this county is in Twisp,” Hover said. “Otherwise, I would have said, ‘It’s a moot point. We can’t do it over there. We do not have industrial water.’”
The industrial zone is just south of Twisp, near the airport. That restriction was a mistake — with no valid zones, the proposal should have classified data centers as unpermitted, Hover said.
That doesn’t mean data centers can’t locate in Okanogan County, since they could be allowed in individual cities, which have their own industrial zones. Planning Commissioner Stacy Storm noted that it’s important to educate the public, because many people may not understand that a county ban would not include cities. Industrial zones in cities typically have water and power set aside for them, Hover said.
In addition to the proposed zoning change, the county asked for public comment on a list of definitions for various technology facilities colloquially described as data centers — data centers, high-intensity computing use, server farms, and cryptocurrency mining operations.
The county code also needs a definition of an earth center or station, to protect the Brewster Teleport, which has been in existence for decades, Hover said. The teleport operates more than 100 satellite antennas that support government and commercial customers, with the primary function of communication with spacecraft, satellites and/or terrestrial-based telecommunications, U.S. Electrodynamics General Manager Darryl White said at the August hearing.
Okanogan County proposed the changes to the zoning code because interest in large-scale computing facilities has raised concerns about demand for electricity and water and about noise and compatibility in rural and residential areas, Okanogan County Planning Director Stephanie “Pete” Palmer said at the August hearing.
Excessive demands
Among the biggest concerns about data centers is their need for huge amounts of power and water. The county and planning commissioners both expressed concern about diverting scarce water from agriculture to data centers.
Adequate power is already an issue in Okanogan County. Hover noted that the Okanogan County Public Utility District (PUD) imposed a moratorium on new high-demand hook-ups for enterprises such as indoor cannabis farms, data centers and cryptocurrency operations. The situation could be different if a data center operator wanted to build its own power plant and offer power supply to others, he said.
As summers become hotter and drier, Hover worries about power shortages during the summer. If farmers can’t water their hay or crops, it would have a significant impact, he said.
Several of the county and planning commissioners said they were concerned that wealthy corporations that operate data centers would buy up ranchland and irrigation rights, ultimately taking land out of production and permanently transferring water rights out of the county.
Moreover, as technology changes, data centers could become obsolete in a short time, the planning commissioners said.
Planning commissioner Salley Bull decried the specter of switching water and power use to industry, particularly at a time when irrigation districts shut down early and the power grid is maxxed out. She said she is totally opposed to data centers.
Companies would locate data centers here to make money, not to be part of the fabric of the community, Crandall said. Okanogan County is a rural, frontier county, and the message from rural Americans is that they don’t want data centers, Hover said.
Other experiences
Because data centers have become so contentious, Planning Commissioner Phil Dart decided to call officials in Quincy, where several data centers have been operating for a decade, to learn about their experience firsthand.
Although there are issues in Quincy, they’re not nearly as bad as people say, and the centers’ benefits far outweigh the problems, Dart said. The biggest issue is power use, since data centers account for almost three-quarters of the city’s total power consumption, he said.
The data centers in Quincy also create noise issues, particularly during monthly tests of back-up generators, Dart said. Positive factors include additional tax revenue and jobs. Quincy has a new city hall, a new high school and a new jail, and a sports complex is under construction, he said.
While he didn’t have a tally of the number of regular jobs once data centers are up and running — it appears that many jobs are done remotely — the centers bring significant employment to an area during construction, Dart said. Typically, data centers have one on-site technician, with the rest of jobs done remotely, Okanogan County Assessor Larry Gilman said.
Data centers provide some tax benefits, but those benefits come primarily from the tax on business personal property, since, unlike large retailers such as Walmart or North 40 Outfitters, data centers are not high-value buildings, Gilman said.
On the other hand, the technology companies that operate data centers regularly challenge the assessed value on business property. These costly challenges drag on for years and are typically successful, meaning that ultimately municipalities have had to repay the taxes, Gilman said.
One option under discussion is to impose a six-month moratorium on any data centers while the county studies the issue, Hover said. Another is to allow them in certain areas but require a conditional-use permit.
Trying to find a sweet spot to fine-tune a conditional-use permit seems very difficult, Crandall said. These corporations are extremely wealthy and have limitless resources, with lawyers and other expertise that could bankrupt the county in the event of a conflict, he said.
The planning commission will discuss the topic further before making a recommendation to the county commissioners. They are considering inviting representatives from the PUD and Okanogan County Electric Co-operative to provide input. Their next meeting is Oct. 26.





