• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • ADVERTISE
  • NEWSSTANDS
  • ABOUT
  • STAFF
  • CONTACT
  • BUSINESS DIRECTORY

Methow Valley News

Locally grown, internationally known

  • NEWS
  • ARTS
  • SPORTS
  • BUSINESS
  • OPINION
    • Letters to the Editor
    • No Bad Days
    • Editorials
    • Hello?
    • My Turn
    • Harts Pass
    • Cartoons
  • OBITUARIES
  • VALLEY LIFE
    • Mazama
    • Winthrop
    • Twisp
    • Lower Valley
    • Off the Wall
  • SENIORS
  • CALENDAR
  • LEGALS
  • CLASSIFIEDS
  • MORE…
    • Crosswords
    • Sudoku
    • Announcements
    • Photos
    • Naked Eye
    • Special Features
    • Readers Write
  • FACEBOOK

Okanogan County adds two lawyers for indigent defendants

May 16, 2024 by Marcy Stamper

Hiring, local funding challenges still remain

The situation for people in Okanogan County who can’t afford a lawyer — and for the attorneys who represent them in court — has improved, with two lawyers joining the county’s public defense team and more money for indigent defense available through the end of the year. 

One attorney started at the end of April and the other starts next week, Anna Burica of Burica Law, who holds the contract for public defense work for Okanogan County, said last week. One lawyer will work full-time on cases in Okanogan County Superior Court, and the other will work a 75% schedule in District Court. Neither attorney is based in Okanogan County, so both will handle many cases remotely, traveling to the county as needed for trials, certain hearings, and to meet with clients, Burica said.

The additional attorneys and money from the county “will keep us afloat a little longer,” Burica said. Because the state places limits on the number of cases each attorney can handle, Burica and another attorney expect to reach their limit by August, she said. 

Those case limits are changing, too. New standards limits will change the number of cases each attorney handles “pretty drastically,” Burica said.

Recommendations on caseloads by the Washington State Bar Association’s (WSBA) Council on Public Defense were adopted in March. The state Supreme Court asked the Bar Association to review existing standards and make recommendations. The high court is expected to review the standards and may adopt the new limits as court rules, Council on Public Defense Chair Jason Schwarz said.

Okanogan County, like many counties across the state, follows the WSBA standards, so the new numbers will fundamentally change legal representation for indigent defendants in the county, Burica said. About 80% of all cases in Washington qualify for indigent defense.

Rather than apply a uniform limit for felonies and misdemeanors, WSBA assigned credits based on the complexity of a case, recognizing that representing a client on a murder charge is considerably more involved than for a stolen vehicle, Schwarz said. The credits are based on empirical research from 17 states, he said.

Under current standards, at 150 felonies per year, a full-time lawyer could spend only 11 hours on each case — and it’s clear people are putting in more hours than that, Schwarz said. Under the new standards, a felony attorney could handle a maximum of 47 case credits per year. Attorneys representing people on misdemeanors can take 400 cases annually.

The new standards are fine — indigent people need defense — but the state needs to pay for all the additional lawyers, Okanogan County Commissioner Andy Hover said. The county’s Human Resources Director is calculating the potential cost, but it would be “in the millions,” he said. Hover has called the state’s approach “an unfunded mandate.”

Washington has no state-run system to regulate public defense, and there were no standards at all until the Supreme Court asked the Bar Association in 2010 to develop guidelines, Schwarz said. 

Washington is also one of just 12 states in the country that provide only minimal funding for indigent defense, leaving counties to scramble to find the money to pay these attorneys. Twenty-seven states fully fund public defense, and 11 use a mix of state and county funding, according to the Washington State Association of Counties (WSAC).

22 new lawyers needed

The new standards will be phased in over the next four years, with the first case reduction required in July 2025 and the final change in 2028, Burica said.

The new numbers mean that Okanogan County will need 10 full-time attorneys for Superior Court cases, another 10 in District Court, and two in juvenile court. That’s a huge increase, since current contracts (a mix of full- and part-time) add up to just over three attorneys, Burica said. Burica handles some cases as well as administrative duties.

It’s going to be very difficult to find 22 attorneys to do full-time criminal work, Burica said. The pool for new attorneys is not encouraging — right now, there aren’t even 10 attorneys in Okanogan County, including those in private practice, who practice criminal law on the defense side, she said.

Okanogan County will also need 17 legal assistants to help with investigations and mitigation, Burica said. Mitigation specialists look at a defendant’s entire history — such as family issues or abuse — and can help build a case that avoids the maximum penalty, she said.

The new standards sparked a big conversation at a recent conference of the Washington Defender Association, Burica said. While many public defenders recognize the need for more realistic caseloads, they worry that, even with all the money in the world, there simply aren’t enough attorneys to provide the necessary staffing, she said. 

Burica agreed that caseloads need to decrease, but wondered if the change should be phased in over 10 years instead of four. 

The situation is complicated by a drop in law-school enrollment nationwide. There was an average of 43,000 first-year students from 1988 through 2000, but then enrollment grew, peaking at 52,400 in 2010. After that, there was a steep drop for four years, ultimately stabilizing at about 38,000 new law students annually.

The standards are likely to generate considerable competition, since all counties will be hiring. Prospective applicants will need to want to work and live in Okanogan County, because places like Bellingham will also be hiring lawyers, she said. 

Schwarz acknowledged that it’s “an understatement” that counties and cities can’t pay for the necessary staffing. WSBA looked at best practices, not the cost, he said.

One hope is that the updated standards will help recruit new public defenders by offering a more reasonable work/life balance, Schwarz said. “It’s a start — it absolutely won’t solve the problem or fill the gap,” he said.

Minimal funding in state budget

The state Legislature has also appropriated a small amount of money for public defense. That includes $900,000 (split between cities and counties) to improve the quality of public defense services. The additional money from the Legislature for training is “a drop in the hat,” Hover said.

Another $1.86 million will go toward internships and training, in part with the aim of encouraging attorneys to practice in rural areas. Some appropriations are specifically for representation connected with drug crimes, parents programs, and cases involving the insanity defense.

The right to effective assistance of counsel, regardless of ability to pay, is guaranteed by the U.S. and Washington constitutions. But while the state requires the county to provide indigent defense services, it pays just 5% of the county’s costs, Hover said.

WSAC filed a lawsuit last year, charging that the state’s indigent defense system was unconstitutional and asking the court to direct the state to provide adequate funding from dependable and regular state sources. 

A Thurston County Superior Court judge dismissed the lawsuit this March. The judge found that, while there is “no dispute that there are serious challenges facing our system providing criminal indigent defense in this state and across the country,” counties can’t assert claims based on the right to counsel, since those rights are held by individual indigent criminal defendants. WSAC is reviewing its options for next steps.

Representatives for the legal profession, in conjunction with law enforcement officials, have been exploring other solutions, such as reducing charges for minor misdemeanors to infractions, where the penalty would be a fine or participation in a diversion program that uses treatment to keep someone out of jail, Burica said. Some charges, such as driving with license suspended in the third degree, are often connected with failure to pay a fine or child support rather than behavior that makes someone a hazard on the road, she said.

Okanogan County is considering investment in better audio-visual technology in the courthouse, which would save money by allowing more remote appearances, Burica said. The system would be “pretty spendy,” but would help, since the county wouldn’t have to pay for travel time for an out-of-county attorney, Hover said.

Filed Under: LATEST NEWS, NEWS

Primary Sidebar

Today

Twisp, WA
48°
Cloudy
7:03 am4:25 pm PST
Feels like: 48°F
Wind: 2mph SSE
Humidity: 81%
Pressure: 29.8"Hg
UV index: 0
FriSatSunMon
57°F / 39°F
52°F / 39°F
50°F / 32°F
48°F / 28°F
powered by Weather Atlas

Footer

© 2026 · Methow Valley News